Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Anchorage Style Guide... blech.

Okay, clearly my feelings regarding the Anchorage Style Guide are not hidden. I wrote an article for it because I'm going to grad school for Fashion Journalism and frankly, the more I can get my work out there, the better. But I must say, I'm kind of embarrassed to even be involved in this "publication" (in parenthesis because I think other publications might be ashamed to even be mentioned in the same category).

I'm a huge believer in excellence. What I mean by that is that I think that when you do something, anything, you should try to do it to the best of your abilities. You should take training to excel and hone your skills, and you should always be looking to make yourself better. I have been a barista for about a year and a half and I can't tell you how much it drives me insane to see people making shitty espresso. Not because I drink coffee religiously or even because I care that much about my own coffee, but because I think when you don't care about your craft, it says something about you. I don't plan on being a barista for the rest of my life, but I don't want to be ignorant about anything I do. I learned how to make excellent coffee and every time I pull a shot or steam milk, I'm training to be better.

That is all to illustrate my philosophy on pretty much all of life and to give you a basis for my critique. Now, on to the Anchorage Style Guide. On a continuum of magazine quality, from your ugliest, worst designed, most terribly written publication to, say, a Vogue or NYLON type magazine... ASG falls millimeters from the "ugliest, worst designed, most terribly written" end. I know, I know, I'm being pretty harsh -- I have high standards, people. And I've done this before, so I know this can be done better. (I no longer have a scanner so you'll have to deal with my photobooth photos and facial responses...)

My main problem:
The design is atrocious. I don't even know where to start, or if I even want to. Backgrounds= all pixelated. Which I find to be quite a feat for a half size magazine. Full spreads are only 11 inches! I don't know what resolution these people are using , but it's decidedly unsatisfactory. Lets keep it concise: Fonts=horrifying. Layouts=repulsive. Photography=mediocre at best. It's a shame because I'm sure there are talented people in Anchorage, but this magazine is not representative of any of them.


ASG, this is how it's done. I don't mean to be snarky or a tooter of ones own horn, but why is ASG so bad, when I can do this on my own with two or three volunteer staff members?





Secondary issues:
The fashion commentary in and of itself is just not great. Winter must-have accessories are over-the-knee boots, purple stuff, and cool headphones. I'm on board with the boots, but purple? Headphones? There weren't two other things that were more "must-have" than purple accessories and cool headphones? I'm baffled.
Photography. Granted, a good layout can make mediocre photography look better, but pair mediocre photography with an awful layout, and the result is terrible images. I'm not even a professional photographer and I know that I could have produced better images. And since we live in Alaska, why not take advantage of the incredible scenery in your images? Only one image in the whole magazine is outside, and it's on a lawn.

I love these images we took out at Beluga Point and in my own backyard. Why are there none of these kinds of images? Why, I say, Why???



I will say one positive thing about ASG. They picked a damn good make-up artist. Tess Weaver did my make-up for my photoshoot with Josh Newton and she's just a doll.

Anchorage Style Guide, do not feel singled out (well, do, but understand why). I will shred to bits any publication which is sub-par. Especially ones which are sub-par while attempting to be anything but (for example, the Wheels n Deals is exempt from my wrath). Things not exempt include the fonts Papyrus and Curlz, all fashion/style/art/music publications, almost all websites, newspapers, etc.
Perhaps I'm so disappointed because this is my hometown. I wish great things for this little city in the north. It hurts me so when people bring it down by doing things like this ASG. It deserves better. I almost want to say, "screw grad school" and give this city a magazine it deserves.



Okay, I got that out of my system.

Etsy update anyone?
I have a couple of new bootstraps up, and I still have my fascinators up, which would make great Christmas presents for fashionable friends and loved ones! I think I'm going to shut down ye olde etsy shoppe, as I doubt I'll be able to keep it up at school...

Etsy: Your place to buy & sell all things handmade
elcamino70.etsy.com

21 musings:

words evaded said...

Jeeesh yours was so much better than the Anchorage Style Guide! Is there any way you can write them suggestions or anything? (if you really do want to help but it's not feasible with your school plans)

le blog de leen said...

wow that's pretty harsh! i wish i could see that guide ( you don't come across such a bad mag every day!)

leen

Elisa said...

WoW! I always though when you have to do something you have to do it at the best or not do it at all. You are the first person I've known who think the same!
I wish I could see this guide, it has to be really ugly!

Parapluie said...

From the photos it does look rather terrible!

Mb said...

If I was on the ASG I would be knocking down doors to bring you on board after that review. You could bring a lot to their writing & layout team.

PS- lovin' the etsy shop. excellent Xmas goodies.

Linda said...

Wow thats bad! Soo soo bad! Ugh!
I always rip "Fashion Magazine" to shreds too...and its not like its bad, it's just not good. You know? All the components are there, but after I am done with the magazine I think "hmm, I got nothing out of this". I hate HATE pixellated images...surely you can tell the difference. I agree with you rant.

Camilla said...

Hahah, ASG was pretty rubbish haha xxx
Love the photos of you! xxx Camilla

Rainbowpavingstones.blogspot.com

Daisy said...

That is such a shame ! But maybe they can benefit from your wise words ! :)

fashion westie said...

I have a strange need to see this hideousness you call ASG....I can't believe someone paid money to put that out.....

anne said...

you tell em sista! hahaha it is amazing that people spend tons of money to put out such things. and even more amazing that someone buys it.

Orchid Grey said...

i too am of the " if you're gonna go, go all they way" mindset, this publication IS sad and looks like it was designed by a middle school graphics class- let 'em have it!

Jeni said...

Loving all your Etsy items, particularly the bootstraps!

p.s. any tips on how to make the perfect cup of coffee?!

jeniwren.com

Rachel C. said...

You should write a letter to the editor (assuming you haven't)! Let them know how you feel, what you would change and be proactive about it - it could end up seriously benefiting you on your own path to fashion journalism. :)

xoxoxo

Rachael.observing said...

less than satisfactory magazine layouts make me angry as well ): and you had so much talent in yours. Its really cool that you are choosing to pursue fashion journalism maybe you can help prevent these issues in the future :). The industry needs you!

indigotangerine said...

your magazine looks far better than that style guide, your graphics and layout are excellent.
-indigo

AlexaRaye said...

Wow! That is pretty bad...

Jen said...

you look absolutely drop dead gorgeous in those pictures :) such a lovely location

Tink in My Closet said...

I love how passionate you are. If i came across a magazine so poorly put together I'd probably just chuck it aside and forget about it- the magazine world needs more people like you to make things better!

Please put together your own magazine:) I will suscribe instantly!!

Christina said...

Hi! I've been a reader for a couple months; this is my first time commenting. I completely agree with your opinion about ASG. I don't have any formal schooling in graphic design but I've experimented with it as a hobby and that magazine is just painful.

I was curious if you have any tips for running a successful Etsy shop. I'm taking next semester off of school and looking for something to occupy my time and possibly provide some extra cash. I was thinking about selling my vintage clothing finds on Etsy, but I'm worried that I'll put all kinds of effort into setting it up and then never sell a thing. Any tips?

Rebecca, The Clothes Horse said...

Oh it does look pretty terrible and your facial expressions say everything! Reminds me of how people here keep saying they want to make Seattle a fashion mecca...but they're so clueless as to what does look good!

idée_géniale said...

Hi! wow, SF really?! I'm so jealous. I really want to move back to the west coast soon, if only I could line up a job in cisco (thats what the hipsters are calling it btw) I'd be there in a second, or a 5 hour flight....you know what I mean.

 
Real Time Web Analytics